The Gershwins’ Porgy and Bess – on Broadway

January 25, 2012

Print Friendly

The Gershwins’ Porgy and Bess

Music by George Gershwin

Lyrics by Ira Gershwin

Porgy and Bess

 
This has been one very talked about, heatedly debated and somewhat controversial revival – really re-working of “Porgy and Bess”.  This production takes the Gershwin’s original opera and changes it – both book and musically to make it into a theatre piece.  How well they’ve done it – or really if they even should have done it – is a matter of high feeling – on both sides.

I will say out front – I’m a fan of the opera “Porgy and Bess’ – but despite that, I was very interested and excited about the piece being re-imagined.  The music is so lovely and has some really interesting characters.  In the opera, which can feel very long in some places and the overwhelming-ness of the score can be a bit much for people – so I thought I streamlined version, with a bit more book and maybe a bit less full-opera-chorus would bring this American classic to a whole new range of people.  I was really behind the idea and looked forward to seeing it.

But once I did, I found itself stranded in a middle zone of part-opera/part-Broadway, and in the end, not enough of either.  The singers are all first-rate…but an example of the middle-ground-problem – the women sang their pieces in a very ‘operatic style’ but the guys sang like Broadway performers…and the two styles did not go well together.

So while I can’t whole-heartedly recommend it – if you are at all interested, do go and experience it.   And like I said, they can all sing – every last one of them…and the score, though a bit messed with, is still chock-full of that beautiful Gershwin music.   This will be a production that is talked about for years to come – and it’s always  fun when you can chime in on something like this armed with first-hand experience.

Richard Rodgers Theatre
226 West 46th Street
between Broadway and 8th Avenue
Now through September 30th

Share
Filed Under: Entertainment, NYC, Theatre

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: